Your customer may see a clear promise in your advertising, then live a completely different experience on a second visit. Customers don't measure your best day; they remember the days that actually met them.
Test the promise when conditions aren't ideal.
Start with two shifts: one where everything goes as planned, and one where a key employee is absent and a supplier is late. Do service time, the way people are treated, and product quality stay within the limit you promised? If the answer changes radically, the problem is in the system that delivers the promise.
Write one sentence describing what the customer actually buys. Ask three employees to write the same sentence, each on their own. Differing answers reveal a gap before it shows up in a review or a complaint.
Fix one link
Draw the promise chain: positioning, promise, system, repetition, and proof. Identify the weakest link, then choose one indicator to measure its improvement over the following weeks. Spending more on reach while the experience varies means more people will see the promise before they test its weakness.
The practical question: what will a customer who came back three times this quarter see, rather than a customer who visited on your best day?